Journal Design Engineering Masthead
African Civil Engineering Journal | 06 July 2009

A Bayesian Hierarchical Model for Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Manufacturing Systems in Rwanda

A Methodological Evaluation
J, e, a, n, d, e, D, i, e, u, U, w, i, m, a, n, a, ,, C, l, a, r, i, s, s, e, U, w, a, s, e, ,, S, a, m, u, e, l, N, i, y, o, n, s, h, u, t, i, ,, V, a, l, é, r, i, e, M, u, k, a, m, u, r, e, n, z, i
Bayesian hierarchical modellingcost-effectiveness analysismanufacturing systemsdeveloping economies
Superior uncertainty quantification compared to frequentist alternatives.
95% credible intervals for cost-effectiveness ratios achieved nominal coverage.
Framework synthesises information across manufacturing systems.
Provides full probabilistic inference on key economic parameters.

Abstract

{ "background": "Cost-effectiveness analysis in manufacturing systems within developing economies is often hampered by sparse, heterogeneous data and the need to integrate multi-level operational uncertainties. Traditional deterministic models fail to adequately quantify these uncertainties, limiting robust decision-making for plant investment and policy.", "purpose and objectives": "This study presents a methodological evaluation of a novel Bayesian hierarchical model designed for cost-effectiveness analysis of manufacturing systems. The objective is to provide a robust framework that quantifies uncertainty and borrows strength across related manufacturing units to improve inference where data are limited.", "methodology": "The proposed model is structured as $y{ij} \\sim \\text{Normal}(\\mu + \\alphai + \\beta x{ij}, \\sigma^2)$, with $\\alphai \\sim \\text{Normal}(0, \\tau^2)$, where $y{ij}$ is a cost-effectiveness metric for plant $i$ under condition $j$, $\\alphai$ captures plant-level random effects, and $x_{ij}$ denotes covariates. The methodology was evaluated using simulated data reflecting Rwandan industrial conditions and a case study of agro-processing plants. Posterior distributions were estimated using Markov chain Monte Carlo sampling.", "findings": "The model demonstrated superior performance in uncertainty quantification compared to frequentist alternatives, with 95% credible intervals for incremental cost-effectiveness ratios achieving nominal coverage in simulation. A key finding was that incorporating hierarchical structure reduced the width of credible intervals for plant-specific estimates by approximately 22% on average, indicating significantly improved precision.", "conclusion": "The Bayesian hierarchical model offers a statistically rigorous methodological advance for cost-effectiveness analysis in data-scarce manufacturing contexts. It effectively synthesises information across a system while providing full probabilistic inference on key economic parameters.", "recommendations": "Adoption of this modelling framework is recommended for engineers and policymakers conducting techno-economic evaluations of manufacturing systems in similar developing economies. Future work should focus on integrating time-series data and non-Gaussian likelihoods for broader applicability.", "key words": "Bayesian