Journal Design Engineering Masthead
African Civil Engineering Journal | 12 February 2020

A Quasi-Experimental Evaluation of Manufacturing Systems Efficiency in Rwanda

A Comparative Analysis of Plant Performance
C, l, a, r, i, s, s, e, M, u, k, a, m, a, n, a, ,, S, a, m, u, e, l, H, a, b, i, m, a, n, a, ,, J, e, a, n, d, e, D, i, e, u, U, w, i, m, a, n, a
Quasi-experimental designOperational efficiencyIndustrial developmentLean production
Applied quasi-experimental design with matched treatment and control plants in Rwanda.
Estimated a significant 18.7 percentage point efficiency gain from systematic intervention.
Control plants showed no statistically significant performance change.
Provides a robust methodological framework for evidence-based industrial policy.

Abstract

{ "background": "The drive for industrialisation in developing economies necessitates robust, context-appropriate methods for evaluating manufacturing systems. In Rwanda, a lack of empirical, comparative performance data hinders evidence-based investment and operational improvements in the engineering sector.", "purpose and objectives": "This study aimed to develop and apply a quasi-experimental methodology to measure and compare operational efficiency gains across a sample of manufacturing plants, isolating the effect of systematic interventions from external confounding factors.", "methodology": "A comparative, quasi-experimental design was implemented, pairing four treatment plants undergoing a defined lean manufacturing system intervention with four matched control plants. Performance was tracked via a composite efficiency metric over multiple periods. The core treatment effect was estimated using a difference-in-differences model: $Y{it} = \\beta0 + \\beta1 \\text{Treat}i + \\beta2 \\text{Post}t + \\delta (\\text{Treat}i \\times \\text{Post}t) + \\epsilon_{it}$, with inference based on cluster-robust standard errors.", "findings": "Plants implementing the systematic intervention demonstrated a significant positive treatment effect. The estimated average efficiency gain attributable to the intervention was 18.7 percentage points (95% CI: 12.4, 25.0). Control plants showed no statistically significant change over the same period.", "conclusion": "The applied quasi-experimental design proved effective for isolating causal efficiency gains in a real-world manufacturing context, providing stronger evidence than observational benchmarks. Systematic interventions can yield substantial performance improvements.", "recommendations": "Manufacturing firms should adopt structured, evidence-based system evaluations. Policymakers and industry bodies are encouraged to support the deployment of such methodological frameworks to guide targeted industrial development strategies.", "key words": "quasi-experimental design, manufacturing systems, operational efficiency, difference-in-differences, industrial policy, lean production", "contribution statement": "This paper provides a novel application of a quasi-experimental, difference