Journal Design Engineering Masthead
African Civil Engineering Journal | 07 October 2017

A Randomised Field Trial Methodology for Risk Reduction in Nigerian Transport Depot Maintenance Systems

I, b, r, a, h, i, m, S, a, n, i, ,, A, d, e, b, a, y, o, A, d, e, w, a, l, e, ,, C, h, i, n, w, e, O, k, o, n, k, w, o, ,, N, g, o, z, i, E, z, e
Randomised Field TrialMaintenance EngineeringRisk AssessmentTransport Depot
Presents a novel cluster-randomised, stepped-wedge field trial methodology for depot maintenance.
Framework designed to detect a minimum 30% reduction in critical failure rates with 80% power.
Emphasises embedding lead engineers as co-researchers to ensure intervention fidelity.
Addresses real-world challenges like contamination between units and sequential rollout.

Abstract

{ "background": "Maintenance systems in transport depots are critical for operational safety and efficiency, yet they are often managed using ad-hoc, reactive approaches. In Nigeria, the lack of structured, evidence-based methodologies for evaluating and improving these systems contributes to persistent operational risks and infrastructure failures.", "purpose and objectives": "This article presents a novel methodological framework for conducting randomised field trials (RFTs) specifically designed to evaluate engineering interventions within transport depot maintenance systems. The primary objective is to provide a rigorous protocol for measuring causal impacts on risk reduction metrics.", "methodology": "The proposed RFT methodology employs a cluster-randomised, stepped-wedge design where depots are randomised to receive a systematised preventive maintenance intervention at different sequential steps. The core impact is estimated using a generalised linear mixed model: $\\logit(P(Y{it}=1)) = \\beta0 + \\beta T{it} + \\gammat + ui + \\epsilon{it}$, where $Y{it}$ is a binary failure event for depot $i$ at time $t$, $T{it}$ is the treatment indicator, $\\gammat$ are time-fixed effects, and $ui$ are depot random effects. Inference is based on cluster-robust standard errors.", "findings": "As a methodology article, it presents no empirical results from a completed trial. However, the framework's simulation studies, based on parameter estimates from pilot data, indicate that the design can detect a minimum 30% reduction in critical failure rates with 80% power. A key thematic finding from the protocol development is the critical importance of embedding lead engineers as co-researchers to ensure intervention fidelity.", "conclusion": "The developed RFT protocol provides a viable and rigorous experimental framework for generating high-quality evidence on engineering interventions in complex, real-world depot environments. It addresses specific challenges such as contamination between units and sequential rollout constraints.", "recommendations": "Researchers and depot engineers should adopt this structured RFT approach to move