Journal Design Engineering Masthead
African Civil Engineering Journal | 25 October 2005

Comparative Field Trial of Maintenance Regimes for Industrial Machinery Fleets in Kenya

A Risk-Based Methodological Evaluation
A, m, i, n, a, O, c, h, i, e, n, g, ,, W, a, n, j, i, k, u, M, w, a, n, g, i, ,, K, a, m, a, u, O, t, i, e, n, o
Risk-based maintenanceField trialMachinery fleetComparative analysis
Randomised field trial of 42 heavy-duty vehicles across three industrial sites in Kenya.
Risk-based maintenance reduced critical failures by 32% versus time-based schedules.
Methodology employed a proportional hazards model to prioritise maintenance tasks.
Significant reduction in total unplanned downtime costs per vehicle observed.

Abstract

{ "background": "Maintenance regimes for industrial machinery fleets in sub-Saharan Africa are often based on fixed schedules or reactive practices, with limited empirical evaluation of their effectiveness in mitigating operational risks within specific regional contexts.", "purpose and objectives": "This study aimed to methodologically evaluate the comparative efficacy of a novel risk-based maintenance (RBM) regime against conventional time-based maintenance (TBM) for industrial machinery fleets, with the primary objective of quantifying associated reductions in critical failure risk.", "methodology": "A randomised field trial was conducted using a fleet of 42 heavy-duty vehicles from three industrial sites. Units were randomly assigned to either the RBM or TBM group. The RBM intervention utilised a proportional hazards model, $\\lambda(t|X) = \\lambda0(t) \\exp(\\beta1 X1 + \\beta2 X_2)$, to prioritise tasks based on real-time risk indicators. Key performance metrics, including mean time between critical failures (MTBCF) and downtime cost, were monitored over an operational period.", "findings": "The risk-based regime reduced the incidence of critical failures by 32% (95% CI: 24% to 40%) compared to the time-based approach. Furthermore, analysis using robust standard errors indicated a statistically significant reduction in total unplanned downtime costs per vehicle for the RBM cohort.", "conclusion": "The risk-based methodology demonstrated superior performance in mitigating high-consequence failure events within the studied operational environment, proving its practical viability for asset-intensive industries in the region.", "recommendations": "Industrial operators should adopt risk-based maintenance frameworks, supported by continuous data collection on machine condition and failure history, to optimise resource allocation and improve fleet reliability.", "key words": "risk-based maintenance, field trial, machinery fleet, proportional hazards model, comparative study, asset management", "contribution statement": "This study provides the first randomised field-trial evidence for the efficacy of a formal risk-based maintenance methodology applied to