Vol. 1 No. 1 (2021)

View Issue TOC

Comparative Field Trial of Water Treatment Systems in Ghana: Methodological Evaluation and Adoption Metrics (2000–2026)

Kwame Asante, Ashesi University
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.18972184
Published: October 5, 2021

Abstract

{ "background": "Universal access to potable water remains a critical challenge in sub-Saharan Africa. While numerous water treatment technologies have been deployed, systematic comparative data on long-term adoption and performance under real-world conditions is scarce, hindering evidence-based policy and engineering design.", "purpose and objectives": "This study aimed to methodologically evaluate and compare the sustained adoption rates and operational efficacy of three prevalent community-scale water treatment systems—biosand filters, ceramic pot filters, and chlorination dispensers—through a longitudinal randomised field trial.", "methodology": "A cluster-randomised controlled trial was implemented across 120 rural communities. Adoption was modelled using a mixed-effects logistic regression: $\\logit(p{ij}) = \\beta0 + \\beta1 T{ij} + \\beta2 X{ij} + uj$, where $p{ij}$ is the probability of adoption for household $i$ in cluster $j$, $T{ij}$ represents treatment technology, $X{ij}$ a vector of household covariates, and $u_j$ a cluster random effect. Primary metrics included verified usage rates and functional status, assessed via quarterly surveys and technical audits.", "findings": "Ceramic pot filters demonstrated a significantly higher sustained adoption rate (68%, 95% CI [62, 74]) compared to biosand filters (52%, CI [46, 58]) and chlorination (41%, CI [35, 47]). The odds ratio for adoption of ceramic filters versus chlorination was 3.05 (p<0.001). Key determinants of adoption included maintenance accessibility and perceived taste improvement.", "conclusion": "The choice of water treatment technology significantly influences long-term community adoption, with household-level ceramic filters showing superior sustained uptake under the trial conditions. Technological reliability and user experience are as critical as initial efficacy.", "recommendations": "Engineering design and implementation policy should prioritise technologies with low recurrent maintenance burdens and positive user sensory feedback. Programmes should integrate robust, longitudinal adoption

Full Text:

Read the Full Article

The HTML galley is loaded below for inline reading and better discovery.

How to Cite

Kwame Asante (2021). Comparative Field Trial of Water Treatment Systems in Ghana: Methodological Evaluation and Adoption Metrics (2000–2026). African Civil Engineering Journal, Vol. 1 No. 1 (2021). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18972184

Keywords

Water treatment technologiesSub-Saharan AfricaRandomised field trialAdoption metricsMethodological evaluationGhana

Research Snapshot

Desktop reading view
Language
EN
Formats
HTML + PDF
Publication Track
Vol. 1 No. 1 (2021)
Current Journal
African Civil Engineering Journal

References